Can Reformation Continue?

Can a religious movement born out of reformation eventually become an obstacle to reformation? Recent events in Dallas, Texas, raise that very question. A congregation seeking to separate from the United Methodist Church (UMC) found itself in a legal battle with the denomination to which it had long belonged. At the heart of the controversy is a question much larger than church property or denominational identity: Who has the final authority over a congregation of God’s people?

The 110-year-old Highland Park congregation on Mockingbird Lane voted by an overwhelming majority—approximately 90%—to leave the United Methodist Church. The vote came after the UMC’s Horizon Texas Conference sued the congregation over changes made to its bylaws and articles of incorporation in 2022 and 2023. Those changes removed references to the UMC, its regional conference, and its governing principles, known as the Book of Discipline.

On October 29, Horizon Texas Conference Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. announced reappointments to all positions for the Highland Park UMC and appointed Rev. Andy Lewis as senior pastor. Those who wished to remain in the denomination began meeting at University Park UMC that weekend.

In a statement to the Dallas Morning News, the conference said that the United Methodist Church’s clergy and lay people are in a shared covenant “with responsibilities to one another beyond any single congregation … Honoring this covenant begins with upholding the vows we have made as United Methodists and restoring Highland Park’s governing documents to reflect those shared commitments.”

Reformation. Reformation comes from the Latin reformare, meaning “to form again” or “to change”. In application, the reformer intends to form again or improve the thing being reformed. Historically, the Reformation is the 16th-century movement in Western Europe that challenged the authority and practices of the Roman Catholic Church, resulting in the creation of Protestantism. You can listen to last Sunday’s FRIEND SUNDAY conversation on Reformation, Restoration and Reality at our YOUTUBE channel.

Though they differed in their conclusions, Martin Luther, Huldrych Zwingli, and John Calvin challenged long-established religious authorities and insisted that the church must be accountable to Scripture. Their efforts raised a question that remains relevant today: Should the church be governed by the traditions of men or by the revealed word of God? That was the genius of the Reformation – and later restoration movements – that the power of God is in His word – not in ecclesia.

Here is the troubling irony: Can a religious institution that once challenged ecclesiastical authority eventually become the very authority it once questioned? When denominational identity, governing documents, or institutional loyalty are defended, we must ask whether Scripture still holds the highest place?

In this case, the congregation removed its denominational creed book, name and other manifestations of the UMC and the UMC sued them (see 1Corinthians 6). Though the separation was a step to reform, does separation from a denomination necessarily mean a return to New Testament Christianity?

While the leadership of the Highland Park church on Mockingbird Lane made these first steps of reformation, they have indicated that they intend to remain Methodist or Wesleyan in theology. The first step may have begun with questioning human authority but the next requires submitting to divine authority to be biblical in theology – not Catholic or Wesleyan.

Reformation seeks to correct what has become wrong. Restoration seeks to recover what God originally established.

This is the danger confronting modern denominationalism. Institutions that emerged from efforts to reform religious traditions can themselves become bound by traditions, creeds, and governing structures. Congregations may find themselves obligated to uphold denominational requirements even when they desire to pursue a different course. But should any human institution possess authority that supersedes the word of God?

What God says must settle the matter—every time.

Jesus came to establish His church, not a collection of competing religious institutions. He entrusted His inspired apostles with the responsibility of revealing His will and teaching His people. And He prayed for a unity that transcends human divisions:

“I pray not only for these, but also for those who believe in me through their word. May they all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I am in you. May they also be in us, so that the world may believe you sent me” (John 17:20–21).

How would such unity be possible? Jesus had already prayed, “Sanctify them by the truth; your word is truth” (John 17:17).

The apostles consistently taught the same divine message among the churches. Paul reminded the Corinthians that Timothy would teach them “my ways in Christ Jesus, just as I teach everywhere in every church” (1 Corinthians 4:17). He also warned against pride and division, urging them to learn “Nothing beyond what is written” (1 Corinthians 4:6).

The lesson is unmistakable: Christ’s people must continually examine their beliefs and practices by the authority of His word. Neither religious heritage, denominational allegiance, nor congregational tradition can replace that standard (Colossians 3:17; 2 Timothy 3:16–17).

Can reformation continue? It must! But genuine reformation is not simply changing a church’s name, rewriting its bylaws, or separating from a denomination. It requires the continuing willingness to examine everything we believe and practice in the light of God’s word.

And that examination must begin with us.

If abandoning human traditions in favor of Scripture was right five centuries ago, it remains right today. We must be equally willing to surrender any belief or practice that cannot be established by the teaching of Christ and His apostles. The question is not whether our religious heritage can be defended, but whether our faith and practice can be defended by the word of God.

Reformation must never end where human tradition begins. Restoration must always lead us back to the authority of Christ.

| Don Hooton

Published by

Don's BibleTalkOnline Blog

My name is Don Hooton. I am a disciple of Jesus; Husband, Father and Grandfather. I preach the gospel of Jesus. And I would love to share the gospel with you.