by Don Hooton
The question of whether miraculous gifts of the Spirit continue today, or whether they continued only until they served their purpose is ongoing in discussions among Bible believing people. I want to outline the several reasons here why I believe that the Bible does teach that miraculous gifts that were given to miracle workers have served their purpose and ceased. First, some clarifications.
God has always worked providentially. Whether miracle or not, God is present. He brought Joseph to Egypt though it was by the hands of his brothers who sold him in slavery (Genesis 45:5). The Bible says that when Judah fell to Babylon, it was by God’s Hand: “The Lord handed King Jehoiakim of Judah over to [Nebuchadnezzar], along with some of the vessels from the house of God” (Daniel 1:2). These unseen movements, that we call providence, are from God according to Scripture and equally in sync with human choice and Divine sovereignty.
God has worked miracles without human agency. There is Creation (Genesis 1-2), the burning bush (Exodus 3:1-4), the writing of 10 commandments on stone (Exodus 31:18; 32:15–16), the talking Donkey (Numbers 22:21–35), the protection of Daniel’s friends in a fire pit and Daniel in the Lion’s Den (Daniel 3:ff; 6:ff), and the Resurrection of Jesus – just to name a few. In other words, God never needs human miracle workers to establish His sovereignty.
God has worked miracles with human agency. Naaman was healed of his leprosy without the presence of the prophet. Still, the Bible says that Naaman dipped in the Jordan seven times, “according to the command of the man of God.” (2Kings 5:14). While not present, the prophet’s involvement was necessary to inform Naaman how God would miraculously heal him. Even when Elijah is sent to the woman of Zarephath (1Kings 17:12-16), he does not touch the bread that multiplies – but his presence at her table is what God commanded of the prophet (see v., 9) and the prophet’s words explain what it is God will do through “the word of Elijah” (15-16).
God has worked miracles selectively. The Bible is abundant with words but every page does not contain a miracle. In fact, the presence of miracles up until the time of Jesus were rare. Some have only counted 86 in the Old Testament. Even in these examples, God does not heal everyone – or even His people; Nor does he feed everyone, or even His people. Jesus confirms this: “There were many widows in Israel in the days of Elijah, when the heavens were shut up three years and six months, and a great famine came over all the land, and Elijah was sent to none of them but only to Zarephath, in the land of Sidon, to a woman who was a widow” (Luke 4:25-26). God sent the prophet to just one man and one woman – but even when selective, the prophet is the miracle worker; God is the power.
The miracles of the first century were extraordinary miracles. Notice that Mark tells us that when miracles appeared by Jesus in His day, it was out of the ordinary: “And he stood up, and immediately took the mat and went out before all of them; so that they were all amazed and glorified God, saying, “We have never seen anything like this!” (Mark 2:12 NRSV). Whatever any other so-called miracle worker may have done, it was not anything like the miracles of Jesus. In fact, in the gospels, it is Jesus who is doing the miracles until He summons the Twelve Apostles and “gave them power and authority over all the demons and to heal diseases. Then he sent them to proclaim the kingdom of God and to heal the sick” (Luke 9:1-2). Note that they was a message too: They were to “proclaim the kingdom” because Christ the King. Later when he sends disciples the Bible says, ‘After this, the Lord appointed seventy-two others, and he sent them ahead of him in pairs to every town and place where he himself was about to go… [And He said to them] “Now go;… Heal the sick who are there, and tell them, ‘The kingdom of God has come near you”’ (Luke 10:1-9). These pre-Pentecost miracles were exclusively powers over demons and healings; there is no record of “prophecy, tongue speaking, or interpretations.”
Where miracles cover page after page in the Bible is in the New Testament, and most specifically in the gospels and through the Apostles in Acts. Yet, Jesus did not publicize His healings to create a sensational reputation, nor as an excuse for raising money; rather He at times commanded those healed to “tell no man’ (Matthew 8:1-4, 9:27-31). He healed all sorts of infirmities, with special attention to hopeless situations, for divine power does not fail. And He performed no partial healings. People were “made whole” by Christ. (Matthew 15:29-31; Mark 7:31-37). Jesus never failed to heal a person that He attempted to Heal. None ever questioned the genuineness of His healings – as to whether the patient had actually been ill or was actually healed. Jesus did not heal by faith alone but by divine power. In only one case out of 31 examples did Jesus require faith. (Matt. 9:27-30). In some situations, the healed had no faith at all (Luke 7:11-17; John 5:2-13). But for miracle workers, they needed to have more faith that God could use them. In each case before Pentecost, Jesus appointed and gave them power. Even when John saw another “not following us” working a miracle, Jesus said to not stop him because working a miracle “IN MY NAME” is a sign that he is of me – and will not speak evil and will be of “us” (Mark 9:38-41).
Miracles in Scripture testify to the authenticity that the messengers are from God. When miracles occur, they give evidence that God is truly at work and His Spokesperson speaks truth. In the Old Testament, Moses worked miracles to demonstrate his authority as God’s spokesman (Exodus 4:1–9). Similarly, the prophets were given words to speak from God, and in order to verify their authority God granted them the ability to perform miracles (1Kings 17:17–24; 2Kings 1:10).
Since miracles of the Old Testament age authenticated Moses and the prophets as men of God, the miracles of the New Testament age authenticated in turn Christ and his apostles. Nicodemus, for example, recognized that God was with Jesus because of the miracles he did (John 3:2). In fact, the scope of Jesus’ healings shows the breadth of his authority. He heals the sick, casts out evil spirits, and cures a variety of specific conditions: a flow of blood, a withered hand, blindness, deafness, paralysis, epilepsy, leprosy, dropsy, and fever. He resuscitates the dead and exercises power over nature.
Jesus said that his miraculous works verify that the kingdom of God has come (Luke 11:14-23). Jesus performed healings, exorcisms, and other miracles as a sign that God’s kingdom had come to earth. As Jesus says in Matthew 12:28: “But if it is by the Spirit of God that I cast out demons, then the kingdom of God has come upon you.” So when we come to the miracles of the early church, then, they too served the immediately relevant purpose in redemptive history: verifying the authenticity of God’s revelation and signaling the coming of the new age of Christ’s Kingdom among God’s people.
Miraculous works would follow in these believers of Jesus. Jesus said, “Truly I tell you, the one who believes in me will also do the works that I do. And he will do even greater works than these, because I am going to the Father” (John 14:12). And at the end of the gospel of Mark, he says, “So the Lord Jesus, after speaking to them, was taken up into heaven and sat down at the right hand of God. And they went out and preached everywhere, while the Lord worked with them and confirmed the word by the accompanying signs” (Mark 16:19-20).
These “greater works” confirmed the word through the signs. The “greater works” does not mean greater in number. Though Acts includes more years of time covered than the gospels, the gospels contain the most. Besides, He didn’t say more – He said greater. Second, it was hardly “more spectacular” or “more supernatural” than the raising of Lazarus from the dead, the multiplication of bread and the turning of water into wine; Though blinding Elymas was amazing (Acts 13). Instead, the “greater works” done by those coming after Jesus point to the same kingdom that has been announced in the gospels – established by the fact of Christ’s death, resurrection, and ascension – but the “signs” and “works” of Jesus could not fully accomplish their true aim until after Jesus had risen from the dead and been exalted. Only at that point could they be seen for what they were: Evidence that the kingdom has come in Jesus; Evidence that the gospel is for everyone; Evidence that Christ is the Alpha and Omega and will come again – triumphantly. That is the greater sign.
The evidence of miraculous gifts were present in the early church those these gifts were a problem in Corinth. Paul dedicated more space to answering this question (12-14) than any other problem in 1Corinthians. The Corinthian church had all sorts of charismatic gifts (Charismata, Greek) (1Corinthians 1:7) and he says, “as you eagerly await the revelation of our Lord Jesus Christ, who will also confirm you to the end, blameless on the day of our Lord Jesus Christ” (1:7-8). The gifts confirm the testimony concerning Christ (1:6) that God is truly among them as they wait for the revelation of the Lord, the unveiling of all that He is. Christ will also confirm them in the last day, the day of our Lord Jesus Christ (8).
Paul elsewhere used the same word for more general gifts (Romans 12:6) that are not miracles in the sense powers or healing – but instead common gifts like service, teaching, exhortation, generosity, leadership, and mercy. In Romans 5:15-16 and 6:23, he also uses the same word gift to describe the gift of redemption and eternal life in Christ. He also used the word to describe offices of the work in the church God gave (Ephesians 4:7,11). These are understood as gifts that have their source from God (a man is appointed an elder by God’s qualifications but he has not been appointed miraculously) but are not inherently lists intended to say all charisma are miraculous. He does include prophecy at the top of the list in Romans 12 – but that is the only one that matches the list we consider in 1Corinthians 12.
Every Christian is said to receive the gift of the Spirit at baptism (Acts 2:38). After Philip worked miracles of healings and powers over devils came to Samaria (8:5-8), they believed and were baptized (8:12), even Simon himself (8:13). They plainly had responded to the gospel as those on Pentecost had (having received forgiveness and the gift of the Holy Spirit), and yet “the Holy Spirit had not fallen upon any of them” (8:16), but had simply been baptized in the name of Jesus Christ as those on Pentecost had been. Though Peter and John had prayed that they would receive the Holy Spirit, the Bible says the Samaritans received the Spirit when Peter and John “laid hands on them and they were receiving the Holy Spirit.” Simon, who before had been a magician, saw Philip working miracles. But when he saw that Peter and John were passing the Spirit miraculous powers on to the believers, he said to Peter and John, “Give this authority to me as well, so that everyone on whom I lay my hands may receive the Holy Spirit.” He did not want the Spirit to work miracles, he wanted the ability to impart the Spirit’s power through his own laying on of hands. And Peter said to him, “May your silver perish with you, because you thought you could acquire the gift of God with money! You have no part or share in this matter” (lit., word) (8:20-21). This is affirmed by what happened in Ephesus with Paul and 12 disciples of John who said they had been baptized into John’s baptism but had not heard about the Holy Spirit. Paul said to them, “John baptized with a baptism of repentance, telling the people to believe in Him who was coming after him, that is, in Jesus.” 5 When they heard this, they were baptized in the name of the Lord Jesus. And when Paul had laid hands upon them, the Holy Spirit came on them and they began speaking with tongues and prophesying (Acts 19:2-6). They were baptized in the name of Jesus and would have received the promised forgiveness of sins and the gift of the Holy Spirit, but they did not have miraculous powers to speak in tongues or prophesy until the Apostle Paul laid his hands on them. Christians received power to work miracles from the Apostles’ who laid hands on them. Not just any Christian was given the power to lay hands on others to receive miraculous ability.
Finally, we come to Paul’s statement in 1Corinthians 13: “but if there are gifts of prophecy, they will be done away with; if there are tongues, they will cease; if there is knowledge, it will be done away with. For we know in part and prophesy in part; but when the perfect comes, the partial will be done away with. When I was a child, I used to speak like a child, think like a child, reason like a child; when I became a man, I did away with childish things. For now we see in a mirror [e]dimly, but then face to face; now I know in part, but then I will know fully, just as I also have been fully known.”
From the list he has given in chapter 12 of nine gifts, Paul specifies three. In that list, there is Wisdom. Though the access to the wisdom of the ages in Proverbs was readable to the early Christians, knowledge and application of that knowledge seems to be the focus of this gift. Paul uses the term “wisdom” (2:6) as a figure of the gospel message revealed to Him as an apostle. And to Ephesus, Paul prayed that God would give them a “spirit of wisdom” and the next gift listed, “and of revelation” (1:17) (cf. Col. 1:9). Connected to that is Knowledge. When considered in light of Ephesians 1:17, this gift seems to be the gift of comprehending the message of the gospel in its sweep. Then there is Faith, not the faith that saves because that faith is commanded (Jn 3:16). Rather, this is the miracle worker’s trust in God’s power to use him to move mountains (cf. Mat 17:20). Healing. The power to heal the sick of disease, to cure the blind, to restore the demon possessed. Miracles. This is a broader term than healing and would encompass healing but also include blinding a man as Paul did. Prophecy. This is the act of being given directly from God His words to speak (Deuteronomy 18:18). It is not merely foretelling, but forth telling God’s will. A prophet is not merely a preacher. As God’s direct mouthpiece to the hearer, he speaks the words that God has miraculously given him. Distinguishing of spirits. This gift seems to allow the gifted to distinguish between truth and error, the true and false prophet. Especially in NT age of demonic possession (1Ths 5:20-21) would this gift serve the church for its edification. Then there is Tongues. This is the gift in the speaker to speak languages unknown to him. The first appearance of this gift is in Acts 2:6, 8 where the Greek is dialectos, “dialects”. They are heard in the hearer’s own language.
WhaT PAUL SAID about himself is that these gifts would cease. We know this is true historically. First, there is little to no appearances in Scripture itself, in writings after the fall of Jerusalem, or late into the first century, of the miracles referred to in Acts, let alone in this chapter. Further, numerous historical figures account that reality to be true. Bishop Chrysostom, by the third century will comment in his notes on Corinthians and say, “This whole place is very obscure; but the obscurity is produced by our own ignorance of the facts referred to and by their cessation, being such as they used to occur, but now no longer take place” (Homilies, 1Cor 12, #29).
He illustrated it the point by three comparisions. 1) The comparison of being a child, who speaks, thinks, and reasons like a child. But when he becomes a man, he gives up childish ways. Or rather, he matures to the point he knows what mature men do – and not what children do. 2) The comparison of seeing dimly in a mirror and then face to face. This latter expression is not a reference to being in heaven. Instead, it is an OT idiom of seeing God in the works and words He has given. In this case it was the words Moses had given them and in those words from Moses, the people saw God “face to face” (Deuteronomy 5:4; see also Ezekiel 20:35). It is describing the process of not seeing clearly what God has said – to finally seeing clearly what God has said. The reason we know this is about what God has said – and not about bring in the presence of God in heaven – is because of the third comparison. 3) I know in part and then, I will know fully – even as Paul has been fully known.
Plus, faith, hope and love abide through the process. And beyond the processes he describes. Hope and Faith will be realized when Jesus comes again. Faith will be sight. He is not pointing the Corinthians to the end of all time.
So what is he pointing them to? Each of these gifts deal with revealing what God wanted for the Christians, or confirming the message from God. And even the three he states. Prophecies; that is what a prophet speaks by inspiration of God – unless of course he is false. Because what makes a prophet a prophet is that God put His words in the prophet’s mouth (Deuteronomy 18:18). It was conveying the message of God. Tongues; the gift of tongues was a sign for unbelievers (14:22) so when the speaker said the words of God in the hearer’s native dialect, the unbeliever could believe. It was conveying the message of God. And Knowledge; This is listed among these miraculous gifts and hence, it is not the knowledge that Christians are commanded to grow in (2Peter 3:18) by handling accurately the word of truth (2Timothy 3:15). This was a Spirit supplied knowledge of God’s message that the recipient had not studied, or learned – but it was given. EACH of these was for the COMMON GOOD of the church. EACH of these was to cause the growth and maturity of the body. Each of these gifts will come to and end. If the end is Jesus’ return, then no church can ever be mature before He arrives because these gifts, as illustrated in all three comparisons, are to take is to maturity from child to a man, the complete vision from shadowy vision to clarity – and knowing in part, and finally knowing fully. If we have spiritual gifts now, we are still a child, we are still seeing in a mirror dimly, and we are still knowing only partly. We cannot have it both ways.
So when the perfect comes, we will be a mature man; we will see in those words that prophecy, tongues and knowledge all bring – the “face to face” presence of God, and we will no longer know partly – we will know fully. This is why the perfect is the message about the Man Jesus Christ. Even John said that he WROTE what he DID WRITE so that YOU may BELIEVE (John 20:31) and again, “These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, so that you may know that you have eternal life” (1John 5:13). And Paul said, “if you have heard of the administration of God’s grace which was given to me for you; that by revelation there was made known to me the mystery, as I wrote before briefly. By referring to this, when you read you can understand my insight into the mystery of Christ, which in other generations was not made known to mankind, as it has now been revealed to His holy apostles and prophets in the Spirit” (Ephesians 3:3-5).
Paul said that “prophecies” and the gifts of “knowledge” would be “done away” (katargeo). Vine’s says this word means “to cease, pass away, done away.” Between both of these two gifts, Paul also says that tongues will “cease.” The word here (patio) means to “cease, leave off” (Vine’s). Hence, it is clear that the Divine plan for these miraculous gifts is that they would cease. But when? According to Paul, they would cease when the part that completed their purpose would arrive.
Paul said that the “perfect” would come. This “perfect” (Gr., teleion) is contrasted to the “partial” (ek merons). The partial things to which Paul refers are the portions of revelation the spiritual gifts provided. If these partial gifts related to the “bit-by-bit” revelation, then it could follow that the “perfect” is the completion of that revelation (e.g. a mature man). And historically, that is exactly what happened (Jude 3). BB Warfield or Princeton Theological Seminary wrote, “there is little or no evidence at all for miraculous working during the first 50 years of the post Apostolic church; and there are slight and unimportant for the next 50 years.”
If the gifts were to be permanent, then it would have occurred in every generation of every century to the present because the power is God’s. But the silence speaks loudly; they have ceased, When they cease, they have ceased.
If the “Perfect” is Jesus, then we are still children and will never be mature (c.f. Ephesians 4:14-16). However, had the “Perfect” been a person, Paul would have used a masculine gender. Instead, he used a neuter. Notice even in the KJV. It says “that which” not “who”. Therefore, it cannot mean Jesus because faith would be sight, hope will be realized when Jesus comes.
The Spirit gave gifts to men and women through the laying on of the apostles’ hands for the purpose of revealing and confirming the message of the gospel. The work of revelation has been completed and we are the benefactors of it. Therefore, the work of miraculous empowerment is unneeded today and ceased. The message of the gospel has already been credentialed for us.